Saturday, April 10, 2010

Realignment: Capitalize on rivalries

Now that it seems as though we can finally get past the steroid era, baseball is looking towards tackling other issues in the sport. We have seen the edition of lightly used instant replay, and now their are talks about realignment. The reason that this is being discussed it mostly because of the AL East. The power-houses that are the Red Sox and the Yankees, along with the young Rays, all play in that division. The Yankees had the most regular season wins in the MLB in 2009 at 103, with the Red Sox recording 95 wins , tied for the third best record in the MLB with the Dodgers. The Rays had a down year, sitting at the middle of the pack with 84 wins for the 15th best record in the MLB, a year removed from going to the World Series. With these three teams in the same division, with no signs of slowing down, many are calling for some type of split up to allow for better competition. Logically, there are three different ways realignment could be implemented, but first I will be looking at a concept that involves promoting geographical rivalries.

AL East

Baltimore Orioles
Boston Red Sox
New York Mets
New York Yankees
Toronto Blue Jays
Washington Nationals

No one in their right mind could argue that the Red Sox/Yankees rivalry hasn't been the best in all of baseball. Keeping the pair together is clearly a no-brainer. Another great rivalry is the Subway Series, the games between the Yankees and the Mets. The Yankees often get the better of Mets(see 2000 World Series), and have by far had more success, but each teams fans hate the other team very much. A rivalry that could grow from this alignment would be that of the Orioles vs. the Nationals. The two ballparks are about an hours drive away from each other, and each team looks to be on the rise, which should mean some competitive baseball. I had to throw in the Blue Jays here because they are closest to the New York and don't really have any rivalries as they have been going through a mediocre couple of years.

AL Central

Chicago Cubs
Chicago White Sox
Kansas City Royals
St. Louis Cardinals

This division becomes the smallest division. The Cubs are the stars as far as rivalries in this division are concerned, with fans hating both the Cardinals and the White Sox. The White Sox are familiar foes for the Royals. Those Royals have been getting whooped around by Cardinals(and every other team in the MLB) but the closeness of the two teams has produced a good rivalry between the two teams.

AL West

Los Angeles Angles of Anaheim
Los Angeles Dodgers
Oakland Athletics
San Diego Padres
San Francisco Giants
Seattle Mariners

This division features the all five California state teams and the Mariners, who most people mistake as being from the nation's capitol. The existing rivalries between the Angels, Athletics, and Mariners carry over from the original AL West, as does the rivalries between the Dodgers, Giants, and Padres. This division would promote the rivalries between the two Bay Area teams and the two Los Angeles teams(even though the Angels aren't really in LA.) San Diego isn't to far from Los Angeles but is quite a ride to and from the Bay area. Any team traveling to Seattle will not enjoy it, no matter what division they're in. The same could be said for the Mariners traveling.

NL East

Atlanta Braves
Florida Marlins
Philadelphia Phillies
Pittsburgh Pirates
Tampa Bay Rays

This was by far the toughest division to make. The only three southeast teams were not enough to grant their own division, so I was forced into including the two Pennsylvania teams. The two intra-state rivalries between the Marlins/Rays and the Phillies/Pirates would be good though it still remains unknown when the Pirates will finally be a formidable foe. Also the already existing rivalries between the Phillies/Marlins/Braves from the original NL East would easily carry over.

NL Central

Cincinnati Reds
Cleveland Indians
Detroit Tigers
Milwaukee Brewers
Minnesota Twins

The carryover of rivalries between the Indians/Tigers/Twins will be familiar along with that of the Brewers/Reds. The intra-state rivalry will take place in Ohio, between the Reds and Indians. Also, the rivalry that brewing between the Brewers and the Twins will have a fire lit under it and the Milwaukee could also look forward to a rivalry with the Tigers.

NL West

Arizona Diamondbacks
Colorado Rockies
Houston Astros
Texas Rangers

The Rangers are the team least familiar with the others as the others are all from the NL West, but they do have a strong pre-existing rivalry with same state Astros. The Rockies/Diamondbacks/Astros will all carryover hatred fro the other team and the Ranger fans will have to grow a hatred for the Diamondbacks and Rockies.

Of course, inter-league play would remain, allowing for old division rivalries to be revisited. This alignment is heavy on teams that are in the same state being in the same division. If not most teams will have a relatively small amount of time for games played within their divisions, excluding some teams that will have to travel to and from Atlanta, Seattle, and Florida. The competitive balance isn't really there, which is most evident in AL West and NL East. Those division hold four teams that are currently tough competitors. Despite that, the promotion of geographical realignment could lead to teams saving more money on trips and could increase revenue as fans would be more likely to make an hour or so drive to see a road game.

1 comment:

  1. That was a good read. Ive read a few other blogs with a similar realignment plans based on current and geographical rivalries and everyone keeps finishing with the same issue.

    The new American League would be waaaay to powerful. Of the 11 teams with a team payroll over $100,000,000 only 3 of them would be in the new National League. The new AL East would have an average payroll of almost $112,000,000 with the addition of the Mets.

    Its understandable that MLB would want to shake things up to distance today's game from the steroid era. Realigning AL and NL teams would do just that.. i just hope they're careful.